Create something uniquely yours at our Charm Bar—where personal style meets endless possibilities. Choose from a curated selection of charms to design a bracelet or necklace that reflects your story, personality, or a special moment. Whether you're layering meaningful symbols or adding a touch of sparkle, your custom piece is crafted just for you.
Thoughtfully curated and beautifully wrapped, our Gift Baskets make every occasion extra special. From birthdays to baby showers, thank-you gifts to just-because surprises, we fill each basket with handpicked items tailored to your recipient. Let us help you create the perfect combination of fashion, home goods, and accessories to give a truly memorable gift.
Effortless, elegant, and made to last—our Permanent Jewelry collection is the ultimate way to wear your favorite pieces every day. Custom-fit and clasp-free, these seamless bracelets, anklets, and necklaces are welded to perfection, symbolizing love, friendship, or simply your signature style. Stop by and get linked with a piece that’s uniquely yours.
Looking for a unique and easy way to earn extra money for your non-profit organization? Host a Shop For Cause night at our store.
Founded by Carissa Cillis, a Long Island hometown native, What A Girl Wants is more than just a store—it’s a reflection of her passion for fashion, style, and meaningful gifting. With a love for curating pieces that feel both special and effortless, Carissa created a space where you can find a little bit of everything to elevate your wardrobe, home, and gifting moments.
From fashion and accessories to home décor and unique gifts, our collections are thoughtfully chosen to blend current trends with timeless versatility. Whether you're shopping for yourself or looking for something special, we invite you to experience our carefully curated selections that bring inspiration to every occasion.
Shop online or visit us in-store to discover what makes What A Girl Wants so special.
1188 Wantagh Ave. Wantagh, NY 11793
Winter Hours
Sunday: 12-5
Closed Mondays
Tues-Sat: 11-6
" Love this cute little neighborhood find. Lots of great specialty gifts for people. Found an adorable little box with Honeymoon Fund engraved on it for my sister."
" Was there for the 1st time today. They had so many beautiful things to choose from and the people who work there are so helpful and very nice ! Can’t wait to go back !"
" Thank you for the impeccable service today! This store has the cutest things from home goods to jewelry to clothing. If you haven’t checked it out you must do so ASAP!"
